Editor’s Note: A version of this story appeared in CNN Business’ Nightcap newsletter. To get it in your inbox, sign up for free, here.
New York
CNN
—
The CEOs are not all right.
Just this week, there have been two high-profile face-plants by company leaders who ostensibly wanted to inspire their staffs and wound up doing…the opposite of that. Both happened on video calls. Both were astonishingly tone-deaf.
We had Andi Owen, CEO of furniture company MillerKnoll, admonishing her employees after some dared to inquire about their bonuses and how they should stay motivated if they’re not getting incentive pay. Her response was, more or less: Shut up about the dang bonuses and focus on your jobs. (She later apologized in an email to staff, saying she was sorry her message “seemed insensitive.” (A sentiment that would probably go a bit further if she’d subbed “was” for “seemed,” but whatever.))
And in an unhinged rant, the CEO of a Utah-based marketing and tech company praised an employee who had to “sell the family dog” as a result of being forced to return to the office. He commended the unnamed employee’s commitment, adding that he found the situation heart-breaking.
Clearlink CEO James Clarke, whose LinkedIn bio reads, “husband, father, friend, faithful,” also went off about working moms who are primary caregivers at home. “One could argue,” he said, that such a path is “neither fair to your employer nor fair to those children.”
He clarified: “Now, I don’t necessarily believe that. But I do believe that only the rarest of full-time caregivers can also be productive and full-time employees at the same time.”
(Honestly, James, what are you even talking about?)
In a statement to CNN, Clearlink declined to address Clarke’s remarks in the video, though the company did not challenge its authenticity.
These two aren’t alone delivering tone-deaf missives over virtual meetings. There was also the CEO who apologized after sending an email announcing layoffs while quoting Martin Luther King Jr. Salesforce’s boss, Marc Benioff, spoke publicly about doing a “digital detox” that was “very freeing” in French Polynesia just before laying off 10% of his staff. There’s Elon Musk berating workers on Twitter and encouraging them to sleep in the office. And who could forget Better.com’s CEO laying off 900 people over Zoom?
Point is: With workers “quiet quitting,” unionizing, and just generally, like, advocating for their own well-being and refusing exploitative demands that executives got away with more easily in the past, is it possible we’ve broken the C-suite’s brains? Has their relative wealth and physical isolation during the pandemic sapped them of their normal-person empathy?
MY TWO CENTS
It’s clear the pandemic and subsequent labor shortage has transformed workers’ mindsets, empowering many to demand better pay or flexibility. In a zero-sum power game, that leaves CEOs with less control. Perhaps these gaffes are a symptom of that power shift. Or perhaps the business elite were always like this and have merely dropped their guises while seated in their smartly furnished home offices, far from the rabble-rousers who work for them for a fraction of their pay.
Of course, being the boss isn’t easy — as my editor insisted I say here. But I’d propose a simple mantra for executives when weighing in on unpopular topics like returning to the office or laying people off.
It goes like this: Be a human, or shut your mouth. That’s it. If you can’t be a human with genuine empathy for other humans, especially those who work for you and may be living paycheck-to-paycheck, then just take a deep breath and stop yourself from talking.
—CNN’s Chris Isidore contributed reporting.
Enjoying Nightcap? Sign up and you’ll get all of this, plus some other funny stuff we liked on the internet, in your inbox every night. (OK, most nights — we believe in a four-day work week around here.)
